ChipCenter Questlink
SEARCH CHIPCENTER
Search Type:
Search for:




Knowledge Centers
Product Reviews
Data Sheets
Guides & Experts
News
International
Ask Us
Circuit Cellar Online
App Notes
NetSeminars
Careers
Resources
FAQ
EE Times Network
Electronics Group Sites

  Analog Avenue


Product of the Month: Feb '99
Data Sheet | Fault-Tolerant Analog Switch Family (Article)

Maxim MAX4506/07/08/09/11/12/13 Analog Switches
Fault-Protected Analog Switches, Muxes, And Signal-Line Protectors Offer Rail-to-Rail Signal Handling

The manufacturer says . . .
Chipcenter's Paul McGoldrick says . . .

Maxim Integrated Products introduced a family of analog switch products intended to minimize a prevalent customer problem–protecting switches from transients outside of the normal power-supply range. This new family of fault-protected products features quad single-pole/single-throw (SPST) switches (MAX4511/MAX4512/MAX4513), 8-channel and dual 4-channel multiplexers (MAX4508/MAX4509), and three or eight in-line protectors (MAX4506/MAX4507).

These new fault-protected devices provide ý 40V of input protection with power off and up to ý 36V of overvoltage protection during power-up or power-down. These terminals become open-circuit during a fault condition, allowing only nanoamperes of leakage into the source. To ensure unambiguous outputs, the switch output clamps to the appropriate supply voltage and delivers as much as 10mA of proper-polarity load current during a fault condition. They also feature Rail-to-Rail signal handling capability, low on-resistance (100W max), and on-resistance matching (6W max). The input off-leakage current is 0.5nA at +25ý C and 10nA at +85ý C.

All parts operate from dual supplies of ý 4.5V to ý 18V or a single +9V to +36V supply. The digital-input thresholds (+0.8V and +2.4V) ensure compatibility with TTL and CMOS logic.

It is impossible to estimate how many DGxxx analog switches are in sockets around the world. They have been widely specified over decades in ATE equipment, process-controls, avionics, communications switching, and data acquisition. Whatever the number it is in the millions upon millions. These parts could - and should - replace all of them that are in the slightest bit vulnerable to over-voltage on the signal pins, or where the power-up process causes its own problems. As an example, imagine a world where you don’t have to power down avionics equipment while you start the engines!

Maxim has been working on this problem for many years and in the last 3 to 4 years has believed enough to have thrown sufficient process technology at the solution to eventually get there; the main achievement is the development of a double-epi process which isolates out the p-channels of the switches. This general 44-V process, with isolation, will be usable in replacing relays, acting as single-line protectors, hot switching, and in high-voltage interface products with latch-up problems. 110-V parts are also technically possible at a later stage with the same basic process.

An added delight of the process is that is throws up separate protection circuits in singles, triples and octals that can be used to drive existing problem areas.

In a break from our normal pattern here in Product of the Month we have the designer of the first parts, and the main protagonist for pushing the process changes, telling the story in the article that follows of how the protection circuitry operates.

Needless to say these parts will sell in significant quantities and I would be not at all surprised to see this as the most important commercial parts from Maxim in some considerable time. There is, as an added incentive, no price premium to be paid for a protected switch.

The parts are available in 8-pin DIP/SO, 16-pin DIP/narrow-SO/SSOP, 18-pin DIP/SO, and 20-pin SSOP. As a price example, the quad MAX4511/12/13 are $1.62 in 1000-piece lots.



Fault-Tolerant Analog Switch Family
By R. N. Wilenken
Maxim Integrated Products, Inc.

Maxim Integrated Products, Inc. has introduced a family of analog switch products intended to minimize a prevalent customer problem: Protecting the switches from transients outside the normal range of the power supplies being used. These transients can either be in the form of overvoltages, while the power supplies are on, or in normal range voltages while the power supplies are off. The cause of the problem is the independence of the signals coming into the switch and can occur when at least two independent supply systems are used, or accidental faults occur during either powering up or down.

Switch users have previously controlled this problem in two ways. First, by sequencing the power supplies to the switches; this normally means turning on the positive supply first, and then the negative supply and then any inputs. Second, by using external resistors to limit current into the switch or MUX. This works to some extent, but is not always easy to implement and any mistakes result in large currents and damaged parts. These effects can show up either in system use, or during incoming inspection tests.

Maxim has developed a process and architecture which address this problem. The solution uses on-chip sensing circuitry to detect the presence of fault conditions, then turning off the switch so the faults are not conducted through the switch into other sensitive circuitry. At the same time this occurs the design prevents the fault from causing any more than leakage currents to flow, thus removing the chances of power-damage related chip destruction.

In a typical CMOS output stage for an analog switch (see Fig. 1) N1 is the n-channel MOSFET, and P1 is the p-channel MOSFET. These form a parallel, complementary output configuration, capable of switching rail-to-rail signals. The gates of N1 and P1 are driven by on-chip driver circuitry, with N1 gate being 180ý out of phase with respect to P1 gate (so when N1 gate is at +15 V, P1 gate is at -15 V, and vice versa.)

Analog Avenue Products
Fig. 1.

In this structure (Fig. 1, again) when an analog input signal exceeds the gate voltage by the threshold value, the output stage will conduct this fault right through the switch and it will be seen at the output. Also, if the power supplies are off while signals are present at the input (i.e. there is 0 V on the gates of N1 and P1), then any signal exceeding just the threshold value will be conducted through the switch. These fault conditions can cause large currents to flow into the chip due to the resultant forward-biased diode conditions, causing localized damage in the part, or they can cause a latch-up condition which may destroy N1 or P1. For example, if an accidental signal of +25 V were to appear at the input, with + and - 15V supplies on, the body of P1 (n-substrate) would form a forward-biased diode with the P1 input (p-material), and the resulting diode current would be virtually unlimited. This usually leads to serious circuit level problems. A similar, reverse, action would happen with N1 with -25 V inputs.

Series Switch Structure

A partial solution to the fault problems (see Fig.2) is to go to a series configuration of n-channels and a p-channel with the gates driven, as before, by internal driver circuitry such that n-gates are out of phase with p-gates. If the switch is supposed to be "on" then the N1 and N2 gates would be driven to +15 V, and the P1 gate to -15 V, and vice versa if the switch is supposed to be "off".

Analog Avenue Products
Fig. 2.

This series configuration solves the fault problems of the parallel configuration since fault signals can neither get through the switch nor cause damaging diode currents to flow. The disadvantage of the series configuration is its obviously higher on-resistance, relatively large chip size, and limited signal handling capacity; this circuit will only switch inputs from 0 V to 15 V-minus-the-threshold voltage (this usually means 0 V to ý 13 V or so.) The series arrangement does a good job of protecting the chip, but at the expense of switch on-resistance and signal-handling capability.

The Maxim Parallel Sense Structure

The basic switching element of the Maxim fault-protected family is the same parallel n- and p-channel MOSFET configuration (see Fig. 1, again.) The simplified internal structure (see Fig. 3) is represented by N1 and P1 but what is different is the sensing circuitry which surrounds N1 and P1, and the clamping blocks at the output. The sensing circuitry is the heart of the fault-protected architecture, while the clamp blocks provide a convenience for certain applications.

Click here for Circuit Diagram (Fig.3.)

To see how the circuit works, assume the same + and - 25 V inputs as previously used. Again, these represent fault conditions so the new circuit should both prevent those faults from being coupled through the switch, and prevent the faults from damaging the chip. Taking the -25 V case first, N1 would see -25 V at its source and one input of the N3 sense switch would see the same. This sense circuit compares the (-25 V) input to the reference of -15 V. When the input exceeds -15 V N3 shorts it to the gate of N1, creating a Vgs = 0 V for N1, and with no enhancement it turns itself off. Concurrently, the comparator circuit with its reference of -15 V will cause the n-channel driver to go to a floating state and this cross-couples to the p-channel driver causing P1 gate to go to +15 V (off condition.) With both N1 and P1 turned off the -25 V fault condition cannot be coupled through the switch, and as there are no circuit possibilities for forward-biased diode current from the input terminal only minimal leakage currents flow.

The N2 clamp circuit will be turned on by the comparator output having sensed a fault. This will short the output terminal to -15 V through a 1 kW resistor (value actually varies with part number), a great convenience for ADC applications.

For the opposite polarity fault of +25 V at the input, the P1, P3 and P2 stages work in a similar way, turning off both P1 and N1 and preventing other than leakage currents from flowing. For this overvoltage case P2 will clamp the output to +15 V through, again, approximately 1 kW .

This scheme meets both of our criteria: No coupling of the fault through the switch, and no power-related damage occurring. The design combines the advantages of parallel (low on-resistance and rail-to-rail signal handling) and series (part self-protection and no coupling of the faults through the switch.)

When the power supplies are off, with input voltages still present, the architecture provides the same protection. When the supplies are off (Fig. 3, again) + and -15 V levels will go to 0V. Looking at the -25 V input case again, N3 sense switch will compare the -25V input to its now 0 V reference. This will cause the N3 sense switch to short the input to the gate of N1, thus still creating a Vgs = 0V for N1, and the MOSFET is still off. Neither the comparator circuit nor the clamp has power and the output will go to 0 V through its load. P1 gate will go to 0 V, and again there are no power supplies to operate the P3 sense switch, the comparator and the p-channel driver. With a -25 V input and 0 V at its gate P1 is not enhanced either. So, both N1 and P1 are off for the -25 V input and only leakage currents will be flowing.

For the +25 V fault condition, the P3 sense switch will short the input to P1 gate, again creating a Vgs = 0 V for P1. Neither P1 nor N1 are enhanced in this case, so the architecture prevents the signal from being coupled through, also allowing only leakage currents to flow. As in the -25 V case the output will go to 0 V through its load.

The design works equally well with a single supply or dual supplies, which can be asymmetrical with virtually no difference in fault protection, and no sequencing order is required.

Using The Parts

Using the parts properly requires little special thought with family members designed to be pin-for-pin replacements of many popular, non-fault protected, switches and MUXES. Simply drop these devices into the same existing sockets to get the fault protection. This will then protect the circuits that follow, since we have seen that the faults are not coupled through the switches. The protection afforded by this family extends beyond just switches and MUXES. Circuit protectors are also offered in singles, triples and octals. Each protector is essentially the same internal structure (Fig. 3, again) and looks like a 65 W resistor for the input signal; if a fault is sensed the protector will turn itself off, isolating the fault from the load, and again only allowing leakages to flow at the input. These can be used to protect op amps, ADCs, sample-and-holds, etc.

A typical application of the 8 channel protector (MAX4507) shows it (Fig. 4) connected in front of a non-fault protected, 1-of-8 multiplexer. (The MAX338 shown might just as easily have been a DG506, or any other non-fault protected device.) The MAX338 channel inputs (N01 through N08) must never exceed the power supply values (here ý 15 V) and the output of the multiplexer is on the common pin (a resistive load is shown.) A0, A1 and A2 are the digital inputs controlling the MUX selection. The enable pin, EN, is shown connected to +5 V but it too can be driven by logic when MUXES are paralleled.

Analog Avenue Products
Click here for full diagram (Fig. 4.)

With the channel inputs of the MAX338 connected to the output pins of the MAX4507 they will never see more than + and -15 V, even if IN1 through IN8 see up to + and -40 V. This sub-system provides extremely good fault protection, and at the same time can switch signals up to the power supplies - in this case ý 15 V. Also, if the power supplies were to be interrupted, or shut down permanently, with input signals present, the sub-system will protect itself indefinitely.

That combined circuit (Fig. 4, again) can be replaced by a single package device, the MAX4508, (see Fig. 5.) Here the protection circuitry is built into the chip and nomenclature is the same for both, except that here the inputs are now N01 through N08.

Analog Avenue Products
Fig.5.

But there are some subtle differences between the two arrangements. In the series circuit (Fig. 4, again) any overvoltages present at the MAX4507 inputs are shared approximately equally. In the single device circuit (Fig.5, again) the MAX4508 must absorb these overvoltages by itself, which gives rise to a lower tolerance for max. input overvoltages. To understand this, take the very unlikely example of having opposite polarity faults appear at input terminals IN1 and IN2 in the series example, and NO1 and NO2 in the single.

Assume +40 V into IN1 and -40 V into IN2, occurring at the same instant of time. If channel 1 were programmed by the logic to be "on" (IN1 shorted to common) then the MAX4507 would limit and clamp this voltage to +15 V on OUT1 terminals (the input for the MAX338.) The voltage drop across the 4507 is 40 - 15 = 25 V, and the voltage drop across the 338 is approx. 0 V since its resistance is usually small compared to the load resistance (voltage-divider effect.) The voltage on the common will then be +15 V. Now for channel 2, it has -40 V at its input and -15 V at its output (OUT2 terminal) since the 4507 will limit and clamp the input voltage. Again, 40 -15 = 25 V is dropped across this channel. The N02 channel is not programmed to be on, so N02 to common will see -15 V to +15V or 30V across the 338 channel. So, of the possible -40 V at the input to +15 V at the common (output), 55 V in total drop, the 4507 shares 25 V of this, and the 338 shares 30 V of this.

If this same situation were to happen to the MAX4506 the full 55 V would have to be absorbed by the 4508 channel. This is outside of the recommended 40 V max. across the channel. Thus the 4508 handles + and -25 V faults, with ý 15 V power supplies, while the series circuit can easily handle + and - 40 V. Both arrangements can withstand + and -40V inputs when the power supplies are turned off.

The process and architecture used in creating this new family of products has limitations. The parts will not protect against 110 V ac or lightning damage. They are, however, effective at protecting against the normally expected fault condition cases, such as power supply sequencing problems and the usual mating up of independent power supply combinations. For these cases the family will sense the presence of a fault, shut down the switch, and prevent the fault from damaging the switch. All the family members will automatically reset themselves to normal operation as soon as the fault condition goes away.

Back to Top

Analog Main | Product of the Week | Columns | Editorial | Tech Notes

Click here to get your listing up.

Copyright © 2003 ChipCenter-QuestLink
About ChipCenter-Questlink  Contact Us  Privacy Statement   Advertising Information  FAQ