This month, an AskUs
question lead me to attempt to find the perfect switch, exactly
the type of component that would go well with the Perfect
Battery (Fuel Cells and Radiological Heater Units) that
I've covered in the past.
The perfect switch should
have the following attributes:
- zero
resistance in the "on" state
- infinite impedance
when in the "off" state
- can handle infinite
current
- no minimum hold
current.
- can handle a signal
of infinite bandwidth
- is totally independent
of temperature effects at anything above absolute zero
- an infinite life
span.
- opens and closes
instantly with zero arcing at any voltage from zero to infinity
As you've probably figured
by now, you will not find one unless you settle for something like
a super-conductor
(The NIST WWW High Temperature Superconductors database (WebHTS) provides
evaluated thermal, mechanical, and superconducting property
data for oxide superconductors.), and that's not practical at
this moment in time. Because sometimes those "worst case"
specs on the datasheets are a reality, it's never a good idea to design
for the elusive perfect anything. Singling out any part for perfection
will lead to nothing but headaches. See Beware:
Worst-Case Specifications Can Be a Reality by Steve Hobrecht
at Linear Technologies.
One practical avenue
you can take to find the perfect switch is solid-state relays (SSRs).
The biggest imperfection
of most any solid state switch is false turn on. That is, the
switch turns itself on without a signal commanding it to turn on
at that time. This typically is a problem when driving inductive
loads. The typical solution to prevent false turn on is to
use a "Snubber" circuit. But, I'll cover Snubbers in a separate
Resource
Page.
Maxim
has a paper (How
to Select the Right CMOS Analog Switch) that should point
you in the right direction if you are looking to control low-level
signals. However, in this
Resource
Page, I'll concentrate more on power-level switches.
An in-a-nut-shell introduction
to "Industry
Standard" Solid-State Relays and Mounting Racks can be found
at Industrologic, Inc.
You can build
your own SSR by using parts from International
Rectifier and Supertex.
IRF's
AN-1015,
The PVI:
A Versatile Circuit Element shows a unique application of their
Photovoltaic Isolator. By using the IRF PVI along with Supertex's
DN25 series depletion mode FETs (this type of FET is normally "on,"
versus the more common kind type that is normally "off")
you get closer to that mythical perfect
switch. See Application
Note AN-D18, "High Voltage Regulators and Linear Circuits using
DN25".
If you don't want to
build your own, you can pick up a ready-made one from Agilent in
their HSSR-8400, 400
V/10-ohm, General-Purpose, 1 Form A, Solid State Relay or
one of International Rectifier's
own Microelectronic Relay (MER) replaces for Mercury-wetted reed
relays.
The PVX6012
is a single-pole, single-throw, normally-open (1 Form "A") relay
using a pair of inverse-series-connected IGBTs to form the output
switch. Parallel to each of the two IGBTs is a FRED (Fast Recovery
Epitaxial Diode) allowing low-voltage-drop conduction in the reverse
polarity.
The PVT442
is a specialized telecom microelectronic relay with single-pole,
single-throw, and normally-closed (otherwise referred to as 1 Form
B) contacts. Its intended use is in peripheral telephone equipment
where a connection to the telephone line is required during power
outages. It might be worth a look for your application.
AN-101:
Choosing an Input Resistor for a Microelectronic Relay is something
you'll need to look at, also.
Just as a brief "aside,"
I find it interesting that IRF is
pointing out how bad
Mercury has become for the environment, yet thousands of dentist
put pounds of Mercury in our mouths everyday in the form of fillings,
or say even the vaccines with mercury-containing
preservative thimerosal we give our children. For some reason,
Mercury is not considered toxic waste as long as it is in your body.
Do you see a problem with this picture? As someone suffering
from Mercury poisoning I agree with IRF myself.
Because SSR inputs are
almost universally LEDs, it would be a good idea to review some of
the application notes related to LED drivers.
Agilent
Technologies optocouplers
can be used in an array of isolation applications, ranging from
power supply and motor control circuits to data communication
and digital logic interface circuits.
Agilent's
Designer's Guide to Isolation Circuits is a 82-page
book that contains 50 application circuits. The handbook begins
with a section discussing critical optocoupler design parameters
such as insulation and withstand voltage, regulatory agency safety
standards, common-mode transient rejection, product life, and light
emitting diode (LED) aging.
Marktech Optoelectronics'
book LED
Driver Application Notes covers the history of the LED to
pulsed applications.
Sharp
Microelectronics of the Americas has numerous applications
notes related to LED's and LED drivers.
COMPARISON
OF SOLID-STATE RELAY TYPES
The type of solid-state
relay used in an application depends upon the load to control. Click
on the links below to compare each type and to learn more about
situations where they are used.
The
above is part of Cutler-Hammer
University.
Iif your new to the field, it
offers the 101
Basics Series that will greatly improve your understanding
of the products
involved in distributing, controlling, and using electricity.
The Cutler-Hammer 101 Basics Series is a self-directed, distance
learning program comprised of a number of different modules. Each
module focuses on a specific product group. The 101 Basics
Series is designed to establish a solid foundation understanding
of the products manufactured by Cutler-Hammer and will prepare
you for subsequent classroom and distance learning courses. Often,
the 101 Basic Series or specific modules within the series are
required as prerequisites for intermediate and advanced Cutler-Hammer
courses.
You
can take a look at the concepts for Analog
Devices Micromachined Relays. How would you like a 16-poll relay
in a BGA package (7.5 x 7.5 x 1.0 mm)? They
are are looking for people to give them ideas and applications. Products
based on the µmRelay technology will not be available until
mid-to-late 2001.
Although definition
of the initial µmRelay product has not been finalized, it
will likely be similar to the product described below. Follow-on
products will provide increased integration with various switch/relay
counts, as well as the inclusion of other semiconductor functions.
Initial Product Concept:
16-channel high-density switch
BGA package (7.5 x
7.5 x 1.0 mm)
Power consumption*:
0.3 mW max.
On resistance:
0.5 ohms max.
Input-output capacitance:
50 fF max.
Maximum input voltage:
150 V min.
Maximum carrying current:
1 A (average)
min., 5 A (peak) min.
Switching time:
6 µs max.
3-dB bandwidth:
2 GHz. min.
Mechanical and electrical
lifetime**: 10^9 cycle min.
Budgetary pricing:
<$16 (<$1 per switch)
* Power consumption
is proportional to the switching frequency.
Aromat
is part of Matsushita
Electric Works, Ltd. (MEW) in Osaka, Japan. They make old-fashion,
heavy, metal relays, as well as their PhotoMos
Relays.
One gripe I
have about their home page
is that it is over 650K, a real pain when all you have is a dial-up
connection. I almost didn't include them here because I was tired
of waiting for it to load.
Axiomatic
Technologies' line of solid-state relays includes the following
products:
The timed
relay permits any digital function to be performed on the single
output. The device is typically delivered fully configured from
the factory. No programming
is required by the customer. Depending on the complexity of the
task involved and the number of units ordered, there may be an initial
factory configuration charge if the function is not already listed
in the appendix. An inexpensive programming system is available
for those wising to program the device in-house. Field programming
from a laptop is also possible.
Solid
state relay with turn-on delay is designed to accept standard
input voltages of 24 VDC or 129 VDC. The relay provides for a 3-ms
time delay to prevent accidental short pulses from activating the
relay. It was originally designed for electrical substation
applications.
California
Eastern Laboratories
is NEC's authorized North American
source for photocouplers, solid-state relays, and optoelectronic
devices.
Several design
tips can be found in Optocoupler
Applications.pdf.
OptoMOS® products were the first optically coupled MOSFET devices
for any telecom application. However, there are many other applications
where Clare's OptoMOS® devices
may provide a solution for design requirements.

Clare
has several
styles of SSRs, including:
- single
pole (4 pin) world's smallest relay
- single
pole (6 pin) one relay in a 6-pin package
- dual pole
two independent relays in a single package
- common input
(single input controlling dual output)
- multifunction
telecom switch integrated relay and optocoupler
- integrated
products relay, optocoupler, and other integrated functionality
- linear
optocouplers/linear isolation amplifiers
-
Continental
Industries has several helpful hints on applying SSRs.
-
"Adequate
heat sinking, including consideration of air temperature and
flow, is essential to the proper operation of a solid state
relay (SSR). It is necessary that the user provide an effective
means for removing heat from the SSR package. The importance
of using a proper heat sink cannot be over stressed because
it directly affects the maximum usable load current and/or
maximum allowable ambient temperature. Lack of attention to
this detail can result in improper switching (lockup) or even
total destruction of the SSR. Up to 90% of the problems with
SSR's are directly related to heat."
They even give
you nice clear schematics of what the modules do, I wish more of
the web pages I saw when making this Resource Page did that. Sometimes
there where tables full of descriptions that still left you wondering
what was different between Device-A and Device-B.
Their product
line ranges from 4 to 100 A/660 VAC, with special inputs (such
as 420 mA or 010 V) available on some models.
In the early 1970s, Crydom
designed, patented, manufactured, and created the world's industry-standard
solid-state relay (SSR). Since then, Crydom has maintained its leadership
position as demonstrated by its introduction of innovative products
such as multi-pole devices, high-power printed circuit board mount
types, and with still more to come. Of the 1,000+ products, a
good portion are of custom design (that is, developed in conjunction
with OEMs wanting to meet the requirements of specially designed systems
and equipment). Crydom manufactures over 1,000 different models of
SSRs, as well as a broad range of thyristor/diodes, I/O modules, and
transient voltage suppressers (TVS). Crydom has an extensive range
of SSRs, from 1 to 150 A, in industry-standard designs and mounting
options.
A
Prime Technology Company
High
Reliability DC Control Relays
AC Input, DC Output
(MOSFET)
Fail-safe output protection
circuitry
DC
Input/AC Output
Eurotherm
is a global organization with market leading products in industrial
and process automation.
AC or DC Input for
Three Phase Applications up to 660 V at 30 A
- no heatsink
required
- mounts
on DIN rail or panel
- safe to
the touch
- 1200-V
blocking voltage
- 4000-V
isolation
- zero voltage
turn-on
- bulit-in
snubber
- LED indicator
Some SSRs can
have complex controllers in them; they are no longer limited to simple
On/Off functions. For example, take a look at the Eurotherm2301
Temperature Controller with Integrated SSR.
Eurotherm
Controls Inc announces the release of the Eurotherm
Model 2301, an integrated PID controller plus intelligent solid
state relay. Designed for applications requiring distributed precision
PID control and a high-current SSR in a single compact unit, the Model
2301 delivers. This product is ideal for SCADA, PLC, or PC-based control
systems where there is a need for a PID I/O that is instantly installed
and remotely supervised over a communications cable. The product
contains Eurotherm's advanced self-tuning, high-speed performance,
instant accuracy and trade, and patented diagnostics.
If you'd like
to design your own PID controller, take a look at Zilog's
application note on the subject (http://www.zilog.com/pdfs/z8otp/pid_motor_control.pdf).
There are typically
three kinds of continuous modes of closed-loop controlproportional,
integral, and derivative (or PID for short).
The control
output is set depending on P, I, and D functions of the "error."
Error is simply the difference between the current position (where
you are) and the desired position (where you want to be).
Thus: Output
= (P × E) + (I × E) + (D × E)
If you want
to learn more about PID control, check out some of the back
issues of Circuit
Cellar.
Circuit
Cellar Ink, December 90/January 91, "Magnetic Levitation: An
Example in Closed-Loop Control" by Jeff Bachiochi (Pronounced BAH-key-AH-key).
Circuit
Cellar Ink, Issue #42, January 1994, "PID-Pong Challenge" by
Tom Cantrell.
Circuit
Cellar Ink, Issue #50, September 1994, "PID-Pong: Point, Set,
Match: Using a Hitachi H8 for Real-time Control" by Tom Cantrell.
Circuit
Cellar Ink, Issue #69, April 1996, "Fuzzy PID-Pong" by
Tom Cantrell.
Circuit
Cellar Ink, Issue #76, November 1996, "Self-Tuning PD Algorithm
for the 68HC11" by Kenneth Baker.
- Fujitsu
offers four families of SSR's:
|
Fujitsu
solid-state relays:
|
| File |
Series
# |
Description |
| |
|
|
| 73k |
SE |
Maximum
load current 1.5 A/2 A, 8-pin SIP package, PCB.
internal zero cross circuit type available |
 |
| 118k |
SG |
Maximum
load current 3 A, 12-pin SIP package, PCB.
internal zero cross circuit type available,
internal
output
surge absorber (varistor) type available |
 |
| 133k |
SJ |
Maximum
load current 1 A, 16-pin DIP package, PCB/socket.
compatible with JY relay in size and terminal arrangement |
 |
| 140k |
SN |
Maximum
load current 1 A, 8-pin SIP package, PCB/socket.
I/O modules for interface between CPU and external
input devices or loads |
|
Grayhill
I/O
racks are passive backplanes into which I/O modules can be installed
and removed. I/O racks connect one of the logic side terminals from
each module to an associated pin on the logic side connector for
interface to the controller. I/O bases have an integral processor
and dual port memory chip. The I/O handles scanning and storage
of the I/O information which can be accessed over the bases address/data
bus. Up to eight buses can be stacked along a DIN rail.
Infineon
Technologies has 77
different types of SSRs, along with many application
notes such as "Stacking
Our solid-state relays for Higher Switching Boltages"
(Yes, I know they spelt "Voltages" wrong, but it is the title of
the document on the site). You can find a cross
reference and good general design information here also.
The Hybrid Division of
Micropac Industries, Inc. announced
their new Quad Solid-State Relay, which was designed to meet the demanding
environments and critical requirements of military, air, and ground
applications.
The Quad Relay is processed
in a MIL-PRF-38534 qualified facility to specific MIL-STD-883 test
methods. Micropac offers a wide range of custom
and standard product design in solid-state relays, solid state power
controllers (270 V, 115 V, and 28 V), and remote power controllers.
Omron has introduced
an innovative new solid state
relay (SSR) designed to prevent short circuit failure caused
by external surges in the output and to ensure designers a "fail
safe" condition.
The new fail safe technology
developed by Omron involves precise notching of the wirebond connected
to the internal die form triac (SSR output). When a damaging over
current is present at the triac, the heat generated by the over
current is focused on the stress notch causing it to fail at the
wirebond, rather than internally within the triac. This technology
results in the triac failing open or "safe," thus eliminating the
need for an external fuse or protection circuitry.
In these days of allocation
of every type of part, it's nice to find someone second sourceing
parts. Omron's MOSFET
Relay Cross Reference provides
part number crosses for Aromat, CP Clare, Infineon (Siemens, AT&T),
and NEC (CEL).
MOSFET
Relay G3VM
- 1 output voltage
of 350400 V
- 1 high-dielectric,
5000-VAC version available
- 1 available in PCB
through-hole, SMT gullwing, and SOP terminal packages
- 1 ideal
for telecom and data communications
- 1 dual relay in
one package available
- current limiting
option also available
Opto 22 manufactures
and sells electronic equipment suitable for any process control,
monitoring, or data acquisition application. With hardware like
the SNAP I/O® system, Opto 22 is the world's leading supplier
of reliable, flexible monitoring and control hardware.
Q: What is Opto
22's SNAP Ethernet I/O system?
A: Opto 22's SNAP Ethernet
I/O system is the combination of a SNAP Ethernet brain, a mounting
rack, assorted I/O or serial modules, and a power supply. With a
SNAP Ethernet I/O system and an Ethernet connection, you can monitor
and control both analog and digital inputs and outputs, or interface
to serial devices anywhere in your facility, or anywhere else in
the world. The SNAP-B3000-ENET or SNAP-ENET-D64 brains are at the
heart of Opto 22's Ethernet I/O system. The SNAP Ethernet brain's
built-in web server allows you to monitor your equipment in the
field using only a web browser; no special software is required.
Visit Internet
I/O and check out the live, hands-on demo of SNAP Ethernet I/O. For
a hands-on demonstration of monitoring and controlling real-world
devices over the Internet, you can connect to one of three demo
stations set up at Opto 22's headquarters in Temecula, California.
Each station has an Opto 22 SNAP Ethernet I/O system connected to
real-world devices that you can monitor and control in real time,
viewing your changes over a live web camera.
For more information
on extending the reach of your IT network to include real-world
devices, visit http://www.ManagetheRealWorld.com.
PLC-RELAYs
are the latest generation of pluggable compact relay modules from
Phoenix Contact. The pluggable,
modular, and flexible interface system offers either a relay interface
(PLC-R) or a solid state relay interface (PLC-O) in a modular terminal
block format in either screw clamp or spring cage connections. They
consist of 6.2-mm (1/4")
wide base terminal blocks and pluggable miniature relays or solid-state
relays with practical switching capacities up to 6 A at 250 VAC
in a single pole double throw (SPDT) configuration. A double
pole double throw (DPDT) version is also available in a 14-mm (1/2")
package. There is also a high current (HC) version in the 14- mm
package available with practical switching capacities up to 10 A
at 250 VAC.
PICKER
COMPONENTS CORP.
PCD Series
4 to 32 VDC
input
10, 15, 25 and 40 A
at 250 VAC
Also, 25 and 40 A at
480 VAC
Solid epoxy body
4,000-V isolation
Zero crossing
Switching
Built-in Snubber
Network
High-surge resistance
Sharp
Microelectronics has SSRs that range from 0.4 A/100 V to 8 A/600
V, 12 A/600 V, and just about every thing in between that you might
need. Some of the units come with internal Snubbers, as well
as zero crossing detection in some models. There are two application
notes worth note in relation to their SSRs:
"Photocoupler,
Photothyristor Coupler, and Phototriac Coupler Application Circuit"
(56 KB)
"Solid
State Relay and Application Circuits" (114 KB)
Some times you need a specialized
SSR. For example, the one shown above does silent
audio switching. Allowing you to switch between two channels
with no clicks or pops.
TELEDYNE
RELAYS
The SR75
is a DC solid state relay with built-in short circuit and overload
current protection. The operating voltage range is from zero to
60 VDC (SR75-1), zero
to 300 VDC, or 120-Vrms AC (SR75-2) when connected with a diode
bridge. This series provides protection of AC or DC loads against
damage from overload currents. The SR75 offers protection against
short circuit and overload currents by continuously monitoring the
instantaneous load current and the output switch junction temperature.
If either condition exceeds predetermined limits the relay will
turn-off and remain off until it is reset by removing the overload
condition and cycling the input control voltage. This action mimics
a resetable circuit breaker but with a turn-off time of micro-seconds
in the presence of short circuit currents. The SR75 can respond
to large excess currents fast enough to prevent serious damage to
the relay, system wiring, or other system components.
The related application
note describes the operational considerations when using this
relay and the technical benefits of the features offered.
They offer a gamut of
relays from 100 mA to 200 A.
I know I missed a couple
of the big names in solid-state relays here, but either their web
pages where totally devoid of any data at all about their products
or the site lead me around in circles. I know you have better
things to do with your time just as I do, than waste it on a poorly
designed site.
Stop by the
Circuit
Cellar News Sever
and join some of the
interesting discussion,
or start one of your
own.
See you there...